For Goodness' Sake, Sir Ben Kingsley Will Not Play a Chinese Villain in Iron Man 3

This just in from Variety: "Ben Kingsley is in final talks to play the villain in Iron Man 3, but fans of the comic book character will be disappointed to learn he won’t take on original Tony Stark archenemy the Mandarin." Well, good. I for one am glad that Ben Kingsley will not be playing a Chinese guy. Instead, the Oscar-winning actor will reportedly play a baddie "involved in the spread of a virus through nanobots."

Variety's intel comes not officially from Marvel Studios but through "insiders":

Though insiders acknowledged Kingsley’s involvement to Variety, Marvel declined to comment on the deal, and insiders denied that the character would be the Mandarin, a wealthy Chinese scientist and martial arts expert who, by backing the warlord who imprisoned Stark, was indirectly responsible for the creation of Iron Man.

If Iron Man 3 does follow Warren Ellis's comic book series "Extremis," Kingsley might be playing one of the scientists who lets loose the nanotech serum. And if Iron Man nemesis the Mandarin is somehow involved, it wouldn't be beyond reason to cast an actor who is half Caucasian, like the character. But Kingsley, who famously played Gandhi in his career-making role, is half English and half Indian (on his father's side) -- and those are not interchangeable ethnicities, people.

Back when Jon Favreau was still attached to Iron Man 3 he was very vocal about wanting to include The Mandarin as the threequel's villain, but it's not been officially suggested that The Mandarin's ethnicity might be changed for any reason. (In 2009 Iron Man actor Faran Tahrir alluded to a possible connection between his character and the supervillain, sparking wild speculation that they could be one and the same. This is silly.) Shane Black is now in the writer-director's chair, so any actual movement on the Mandarin's inclusion is TBA.

Besides, I'd think if someone was to play the Mandarin it'd be an actor closer in age to Robert Downey Jr. so they could make use of the Mandarin's superior martial arts combat skills and whatnot. Let's just hope that if it does happen, the filmmakers have the sense to look at Asian or Asian-American candidates. How would you include him at all otherwise (and justify the revisionist comic book history)?



Comments

  • Ben Kingsley will not play a Chinese guy? Thanks, Jen.
    That's good news!
    I think of Mickey Rooney in BREAKFAST AT TIFFANY'S, or
    James Caan imitating a Coolie in EL DORADO, and I just
    feel...embarrassed.
    Finding the right actor for the right job can't be too tough.
    Then again, it's Hollywood. Bunch of boneheads.
    KRIS the KLINGON

    • S.T. VanAirsdale says:

      Somehow I read that as "Mickey Rourke in BREAKFAST AT TIFFANY'S." I'll be cleaning coffee off my desk for a while.

    • James says:

      Or John Wayne as Genghis Khan. The 50s and 60s did some really bad casting and don't get me started on the "Indians".

    • Revenge says:

      NO IT's BAD! MANDARIN IS THE #1 Iron Man villain all you can thing about is being RETARDED!

  • Andrew says:

    Hey Jen, serious question...

    You're always up on step about stuff like this, but I haven't seen a word from you about how Bane is canonly Hispanic and yet being played by a white dude.

    Haven't heard anything about from the racebending folks either.

    What's up with that?

    • Jen Yamato says:

      Andrew - great question. I haven't written about it because I wasn't aware of Bane's origins, hadn't followed the comics to know it ahead of the casting move. But I do find myself torn on this particular example since I love Tom Hardy so.

      However Nolan & Co. have chosen to address it (or not) in the film remains to be seen, but I'm in the camp of casting to match the character's ethnicity. I can't imagine whatever reason they have will satisfy everyone - either you change Bane's ethnicity to explain why he looks like Hardy or you make Hardy play Latino, and both options feel wrong.

    • Max Renn says:

      Because no one else cares as long as a good actor plays him.

  • david says:

    They don't want to make Mandarin caucasian-ish, but they went right ahead and flipped Nick Fury into being a bald black guy. O.0 ?

  • Molly says:

    There may be a bundle to find out about this. You made nice points also.

  • Madison says:

    Wow, great blog article.Much thanks again. Cool.

Post a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s