Those Rand-y Republicans: Nine Films That Espouse The New GOP's Libertarian Mindset
7. Wall Street (1987): Rand preferred to call it "objective self interest," but Gordon Gecko’s infamous "Greed is good" catch phrase is the more pithy summation of libertarian economic philosophy. The brashly liberal and often conspiratorial minded Oliver Stone meant for Gecko’s declaration to ring with doomed hubris. But the fact that this morality tale lands the charismatic Wall Street lizard in jail for his insider trading has not informed the cult-like reception by audiences. And Stone isn’t blameless. The production’s gloss and glamorization of '80s power-suit culture is the movie’s most lasting vision. For all the explicit sermonizing, the posh optics and slick storytelling undercut Stone's anti-greed polemic. As a result, libertarians can enjoy this film on two levels: rooting for a villain in a vicarious thrill-ride through the heyday of modern New York bourgeois culture; or the schadenfreude of watching another liberal Hollywood screed cave-in on itself.
8. 1984 (1984): This worthy adaptation of Orwell’s category-killing dystopian masterwork almost seems too obvious to merit mention. Except that Orwell was invoked by liberals during the Bush administration — much as Rand is now touted by conservatives — as the ultimate rhetorical broadsword. Charges of “Orwellian!” blighted the reputation of programs like The Patriot Act and were levied so frequently that they became synonymous in liberal circles with the Bush administration writ large. RNC libertarians who suspect the “Obamacare” mandate is a draconian slippery slope to memory-hole torture programs might want to reacquaint themselves with this recent classic and craft a timely rejoinder.
9. Atlas Shrugged (2011): Ayn Rand believed objective reality could be expressed though art. Though critics were unanimous that this much-maligned adaptation doesn’t really qualify, watch a few minutes of this runaway disaster to reaffirm your conviction that there are no sacred cows when it comes to the business of being entertained.
Follow Gino Orlandini on Twitter.
Follow Movieline on Twitter.
Subscribe to the new Movieline on YouTube
Comments
I'm pretty sure real Libertarians would be shocked to discover they have taken over the Republican Party... especially since they haven't in the least.
All cineastes know Rocky ended the Cold War with his post-fight "If I can change, you can change" speech.
Gino, you're apparently less familiar with the Republican Party than many would think. The Republican Party of today is nothing even remotely resembling libertarian-leaning. See following article - http://www.examiner.com/article/today-s-republican-party-more-regulation-no-more-free-market-less-freedom
I don't think you understand what Libertarianism is.....
The 1st paragraph is beyond laughable. Libertarians have little to nothing in common w/ romney/ryan/current gop. Whoever wrote that doesnt deserve to have any voice when it comes to news.
To the contrary, you nattering nabobs of negativism, Gino is on to something.
I would agree that Gino is on to something. Having been a Libertarian since the early 80s, there's no doubt that libertarian ideals are more prevalent now than ever. With Ron and Rand Paul in the news regularly and Paul Ryan being a definite admirer of Ayn Rand, there's a lot of objectivism out there right now and much more than in the past. Personally, I like some of Ayn Rand, but not all. I can see how self interest can result in benefits for society, but I am not against altruism like she is. My feeling is that people should be persuaded to be altruistic, not forced by the government through taxation and redistribution of wealth. I'm also not anti-government. I am just more a believer in a small government like the one envisioned by our founders.
However, I have to say that Gino only got about half of these movies right. Brazil is a classic libertarian film--perhaps the top. But Top Gun? This shows a serious ignorance on Gino's part about what libertarians believe. What about Top Gun is libertarian? Libertarians are not pro military. They may be anti-communism, but Top Gun is about as far from our ideology as it gets.
And Wall Street? The faux-libertarian in that film is the villain! He might have been charming, but he's the antagonist in the film. Why would libertarians like that? The Bruce Wayne character is a bit of a Randian character, but TDKR is definitely not a libertarian film (probably simply due to Nolan's muddled and poorly thought out themes in all three films). Terminator is a metaphorical stretch. Sunset Blvd is not really all that libertarian either.
Yes to Casablanca if only because of Rick's vision of self preservation. He's my kind of libertarian. Looks out for himself, but will sacrifice for others when push comes to shove.
GINO! Here's a few films that you should have included on your list:
Enemy of the State (this is libertarian paranoia at it's most Tony Scott-ish)
The Fountainhead and We, The Living (for obvious reasons)
Hombre (Paul Newman as a libertarian native american musing on what a hero is and what their duty is)
The Edge (Anthony Hopkins is the ultimate objectivist hero of all time in this Mamet film)
You should definitely update your list so it's not so off key to what libertarians believe.
Excellent observations, Jake. I would say, though, that what's at the crux of a lot of the critical comments here is that Libertarians --and Democrats, Republicans, Independents, etc. --prefer to see themselves in the best, or purest, light possible. And so, critical analysis of their particular ideology tends to rankle even when its presented with wit and intelligence.
You'll get no argument there and what you say is true. And I should add that libertarians are a particularly difficult group to define because they argue within themselves about what a libertarian is all the time. But one thing for sure, Top Gun is definitely too jingoistic to be a libertarian film. It's a major conservative, pro military film. For it to be listed at all is questionable. For it to be first is sort of head scratching. Even reading Gino's justification for including it makes no real sense. I mean, I don't think anyone walked out of Top Gun thinking, "Boy is capitalism really awesome or what?" But I like that these ideas are being talked about on a movie website, so kudos to him for making this article. It helps that I have been involved in numerous libertarian panels discussing libertarian films.
One film I should add, that I don't particularly agree with personally (because I think it is more of an anarchist film) but that most libertarians call their own is V for Vendetta.
Atlas Shrugged Part 2 will be in theaters October 12th, 2012.
You're missing the point with The Dark Knight Rises. He doesn't give himself selflessly. He always valued Gotham highly. In fact, in direct contrast to the Jesus myth, Bruce Wayne finds a way to save the world without giving his life. Then he disappears into obscurity to finally overcome his loneliness. How exactly is giving up the cape (ceasing to fight crime) in favor of romance selfless?
@grandmofhelsing tells me that "Ghostbusters" should be included on our list because, in the movie, the "EPA is the bad guy." True dat.
A lot of people think they understand what Ayn Rand's morality advocates, but actually don't. Here are some brief points about what it really stands for: The Morality of Rational Egoism: Short Notes
Personally, I like some of Ayn Rand, but not all. I can see how self interest can result in benefits for society, but I am not against altruism like she is. I am beautiful woman and I love good man…..inter racial romance is my dream… so I joined —blackwhitеPlanet.С0M—–it's where to- connect with beautiful and excellent people! My feeling is that people should be persuaded to be altruistic, not forced by the government through taxation and redistribution of wealth. I'm also not anti-government.
>Rand preferred to call it "objective self interest,"
I think you mean rational self-interest.
wow, what an amazingly ignorant article.
My family all the time say that I am wasting my time here at web, however I know I am getting experience daily by reading thes fastidious posts.
Way cool, some valid points! I appreciate you thus, making this article available, the remainder website is also well done. Have a great day