Mystery Men On Blu-ray: The Anti-Dark Knight Rises?

Mystery Men on Bluray - anti Dark Knight

A caped crusader. A city wiped clean of criminals. A madman with a doomsday device who terrorizes the populace until average citizen heroes step forward to help save the day. Batman? Nope! On the heels of The Dark Knight Rises, Movieline takes a look back at 1999's Mystery Men, new to Blu-ray, in the latest installment of Inessential Essentials.

The film: Mystery Men (1999)

Why It's an Inessential Essential: Based on characters by comics creator Bob Burden, Mystery Men is an anomalously charming and amiably goofy superhero film. The film is very much a product of the creative chaos that ensued after Hollywood executives realized comic book properties like Batman could make a mint at the box office. But with many more duds than hits on their hands, execs were apparently clueless about what they should adapt and how to do it. It's not only strange that a movie with characters as alienating-ly campy as the ones in Mystery Men ever got made — it's even freakier to note that the film is actually pretty funny. So while mass audiences didn't know what to make of the film when it was initially released, the film can now be enjoyed as a more than welcome antidote to the recent trend of self-serious but mostly drab superhero films.

Mystery Men was co-produced by Dark Horse Comics publisher and creator Michael Richardson, the man responsible for turning such comic book properties as Tank Girl (1995) and The Mask (1994) into half-baked films. It was directed by Kinka Usher, making a big leap from being the assistant camera operator on such films as the 1987 Kato Kaelin vehicle Beach Fever (Usher would not go on to direct any other movies after Mystery Men, not even short films). Usher clearly directed the film in the style of the Joel Schumacher Batman movies; he makes frequent use of campy Dutch angles, crash zooms and first person POV shots, like the one where we see Ben Stiller being attacked by Geoffrey Rush's character — from the perspective of Rush's extended pinky. To call this film's success as a comedy anomalous would be putting it very diplomatically.

In the film, a group of wannabe superheroes that mostly don't seem to have any real powers band together to fight the nefarious disco-obsessed Casanova Frankenstein (Geoffrey Rush, who had just won an Oscar for Shine two years before Mystery Men was made). Now that Frankenstein has kidnapped the all-powerful Captain Amazing (Greg Kinnear), the only people that can stop him are the then-unnamed group of heroes: Mr. Furious (Ben Stiller), a tantrum-throwing wimp who isn't very strong; The Shoveler (William H. Macy), a middle-class father and a guy that fights crime with a shovel; and the Blue Raja (Hank Azaria), an adenoidal mama's boy who pretends to be a British mystic and uses flatware as projectile weapons (mainly forks and spoons). To defeat Frankenstein, the team has to hire some new members, including the gaseous Spleen (Paul Reubens) and the haunted-bowling-ball-chucking Bowler (Janeane Garofalo). It's a fittingly unusual line-up for a rather odd film.

By today's standards, Mystery Men is seriously dated. For starters, Smashmouth's "Allstar" is used twice as a song cue. But it's also often disarmingly eccentric, as in the scene where Tom Waits, who plays a mad scientist, shows off his arsenal of weird weapons (including the Blame Thrower), or the one where Wes Studi's enigmatic, platitude-slinging hero The Sphinx trains the titular heroes ("To learn my teachings, I must first teach you how to learn"). All of the characters are also endearingly neurotic, like Invisible Boy (Kel Mitchell, of Keenan and Kel fame), a teenage loser who can only turn invisible when nobody else is looking at him, or Garofalo's Bowler, a woman whose dead father nags her even from beyond the grave. Filmed on a reported $68 million budget, Mystery Men only grossed $33.4 million worldwide but went on to earn something of a cult status.

Mystery Men blu-ray - Janeane Garofolo, Paul Reubens, William H. Macy

How the Blu-Ray Makes the Case for the Movie: You can appreciate just how bizarre Mystery Men is just from watching the Spotlight on Location featurette, which makes it seem like the film's production was pretty manic. For instance, Stiller reveals that the film's cast were working with an improv-reliant script. "We're always coming up with ideas, which is the fun thing about..." Stiller says, comically pausing to look around him and finishing his thought, "not having a script." Garofalo and Stiller both joke about the fact that they had little confidence in Usher. "I'm only doing this for the money," she teases. "Kinka doesn't know what the fuck he's doin'. He hasn't directed a movie before." Even nice guy Greg Kinnear chimes in: "I describe [Mystery Men] as...a cartoon gone horribly, horribly wrong." But Usher got results; even the film's deleted scenes, like the one where Waits macks on a blue-haired retiree by telling her that he's actually a doctor, are pretty funny.

Other Trivia: In a rather thoughtful special feature, Burden shares a detailed history of his original comic book characters through interviews conducted before the film's release. It's especially funny to note that the character of the Shoveler was originally armed with King Arthur's singing shovel, which was sentient and talked in "Middle English." Also, apparently, Danny DeVito was supposed to not only direct the film at one point but play the Shoveler, too. Burden is also quoted in a Comics Buyer's Guide interview as saying that he didn't write the characters with modern actors in mind. "Originally, as I envisioned them, the Mystery Men were characters like Ernest Borgnine and Vic Tayback — all Mike Ditka-type guys. The only current star I could've seen as a Mystery Man would've been Steve Buscemi from Fargo."

Previously: Reconsidering Christopher Nolan's Insomnia

Simon Abrams is a NY-based freelance film critic whose work has been featured in outlets like The Village Voice, Time Out New York, Vulture and Esquire. Additionally, some people like his writing, which he collects at Extended Cut.


  • This movie is where I came to adore William H Macy and Hank Azaria and renewed my interest in comic books.

  • The Cantankerist says:

    Aww, c'mon, it's a hot mess. The styles pull against each other all the way through. There's never been a movie to say "first-time director" more clearly, by which I mean the improv is allowed to derail character pretty frequently.

    It does share with Dark Knight Rises the clumsy toying with "superhero", but the problem is the guys are bickering dufuses so often that they lose our sympathy. We should be barracking for them, but it's hard to care. And they never manage to seem like a team: Macy's in a Coen comedy, Stiller's in his own film, Azaria's in a broader kids' comedy. And Rush and Kinnear are doing something else - quite successfully, but still. There's more than a whiff of Mars Attacks about the whole thing.

  • A Hot Mess indeed, its so rag tag mish mash and random that (in a weird way) its everything cool about indy titles of the time. This aint the Avengers (not WestCoast Europe or International) this aint the SuperFriends; this is a group of very flawed people brought together more outve selfishness than a common cause with only mythological tropes (even in their universe) to guide them.
    Oh certainly the directors lack of skill (Assistant camera op to director on a 68 million dollar movie director? Something was going on that we may Never hear about) is evident and hinders things, and letting stand up comedians loose with improv does not always help a script. But the actors behaving like their in different films comes off to me more like an illustration of what a flawed disparate (sp?) bunch of people these are.

  • wendy says:

    An old man can m’arry a young girl, a black wealthy beautiful stays with an common American, even a rat can fall in love with a cat, so every bottle has its suitable lid, I am Candyee, a young beauty, 30 years old. Once, I a feel Life so lonely. I am rich but still s’ingle, later on, I am on ( == BlackWhitePlanet– c 0 /m ==), met many good guys and beauties, they also want to find true love. Now I have found my l’ove , so I recommend it to you, I hope everyone can find their best l’ove.Goodluck.==(( βlαckwhitеPlanet.СòM)----==

  • max says:

    This movie is shown every so often on free-to-air here, and every time I stop flipping to watch some it, I'm quickly reminded why I always avoid it - it's a terrible movie.