Was Sarah Palin's Alaska Really the Worst Reality Show of the Year?


We're not much for Razzie-style hatefests 'round Movieline HQ, but the second-annual Bennie Awards -- a roundup of the worst in primetime television -- brings up an important point: Was Sarah Palin's Alaska sincerely a terrible reality show? One so bad that it deserved bottom honors under the moral depravity of this year's Bridalplasty and Bad Girls Club? Let's sit on our rifles and think about it.

Either way, shame on me (and you, vicariously) for watching every episode of Sarah Palin's Alaska. We could only make so many "ursa mater" jokes about Aunt Sarah, and Bristol could only bludgeon so many halibut. The TLC series was a boring, if harmless campaign for attention, and we should all forget it happened. Done!

But while we're remembering, I'll suggest that it doesn't warrant the wrath of the "Golden Trashcan Award." The production quality alone was pretty exceptional. The sight and splendor of Sarah's floatplane coasting along the Denali skyline smacked of North by Northwest's cropdusting scene (with Todd in the Cary Grant role, and "boredom" in the role of "suspense"). Bridalplasty is distinctively awful and even less entertaining. Or educational. I'm sorry to have brought up that word.

Here are the rest of the Bennie Awards. For the record, Ryan Seacrest is as deserving of an Emmy as constant-winner Jeff Probst is, and I can't stand for any trashing of his vaudevillian emcee skills.

Worst Female in a Reality Program

Sarah Palin (Sarah Palin's Alaska) -- WINNER

Camille Grammer (The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills)

Kim Kardashian (Keeping up with the Kardashians)

Shanna Moakler (Bridalplasty)

Snooki (Jersey Shore)

Worst Male in a Reality Program

Ryan Seacrest (American Idol) -- WINNER

David Hasselhoff (The Hasselhoffs)

Randy Jackson (American Idol)

Kevin Pollack (Million Dollar Money Drop)

The Situation (Jersey Shore)

Worst Female in a Scripted Program

AnnaLynne McCord (90210) -- WINNER

Aly Michalka (Hellcats)

Blake Lively (Gossip Girl)

Elizabeth Mitchell (V)

Jada Pinkett Smith (HawthoRNe)

Worst Male in a Scripted Program

Ed Westwick (Gossip Girl) -- WINNER

Jim Belushi (The Defenders)

David Caruso (CSI: Miami)

Charlie Sheen (Two and Half Men)

Blair Underwood (The Event)

Pushing Daisies Award

Better off Ted -- WINNER



Lone Star


Worst Reality Program

Sarah Palin's Alaska -- WINNER

16 and Pregnant

Bad Girls Club


Jersey Shore

Worst Scripted Program

Hellcats -- WINNER


Happy Town


Sh*t My Dad Says