Gleebasing: Where's the Hate?

Tuesday night's episode of Glee, "The Comeback," was dedicated to anyone who ever suggested that Sue Sylvester -- one of the most deliciously villainous characters on television -- is too evil. Because I am not in that demographic, I will address last night's treatment of Sue Sylvester -- from the fake suicide note to the pediatric cancer ward sing-along -- like the affront to her character that it was. Who's ready?

Sue Sylvester is a delightfully cold-hearted minx. She is at her best when she is threatening to launch Cheerios out of a cannon imported from Asia or telling local TV viewers why caning and littering should be encouraged. That being said, Jane Lynch's character has also had redeeming emotional moments -- like when her newscaster beau dumped her on-air or she visited her sister with Down syndrome.

GleeBieberFever500.jpgI understand that Sue is depressed about her team not making Nationals -- but I wish that Ryan Murphy had dragged the "depressed Sue Sylvester story arc" across a few more episodes, rather than trying to resolve it with a trip to the pediatric cancer ward. You know how people still talk about television series "jumping the shark" -- in reference to that episode of Happy Days in which Fonzie actually jumped over a shark? I suggest that from now on, viewers use the phrase "jump the pediatric cancer ward" to describe the moment when a show died.

Speaking of death -- Emma Pillsbury, you're dead to me. You spent the first season flirting with Schue and tempting him to leave his loveless marriage and then when he finally did, you took up with some dreamy doctor and disappeared for 70 percent of the second season's episodes like the OCD-afflicted floozy you are. Occasionally you return, trying to woo viewers back into your good graces with a cheekily-titled self-help pamphlet ("I Am Too Depressed To Even Open This Pamphlet"), but you can't make up for your absences that easily. You are a deadbeat love interest. There, I said it. Moving on. Now to the actual glee-cap.

In spite of the fact that a suicide would never occur on a network television series about singing and dancing teenagers, Schue and Emma were scared that a newly depressed Sue was on the brink of hanging herself with Adidas pants. So they ditched their scheduled classes (as you do when you are a faculty staff member) and bolted to Sue's house, expecting to find her lifeless body already interred in a trophy case. Instead, they found a sad Sue in bed.

Schue tried to tell Sue that "life is beautiful!" but it wasn't too convincing because his character has been relegated to teaching meaningless lessons and facilitating weak plot points. Speaking of which, Sue admitted that the only thing that made her happy lately was singing along with Charice in her Le Car. Considering that Sue had not had a lobotomy, this is impossible. But Schue heard that false proclamation, got excited and invited her to join Glee club. Because Will Schuester is the most gullible person alive.

So, Sue infiltrated the New Directions -- as she has many times before, but this time in person -- and pitted Rachel and Mercedes against each other in a diva-off. When Schue sensed Sue's ill intentions, he took her down to the previously mentioned pediatric cancer ward. Pediatric cancer ward? OK. Sick kids always put things in perspective. But a pediatric cancer ward with a ukelele and a sing-a-long to "This Little Light of Mine" while Sue tears up with a dying child on her lap? Too much, Ryan Murphy. Too much.

Meanwhile, Sam started a Justin Bieber cover band to win back Quinn's affection -- and Artie, Puck and Mike Chang begged to be part of it since anything Biebs-related has a hypnotic effect on chicks -- except for Lauren Zizes who is still not convinced that Puck is the man for her.


As this was happening, Rachel Berry tried to create a career resurgence for herself... by being shrill and paying Brittany to make her "preppy" style cool. Of course, this did not pan out. But it's OK, because Schue taught everyone about the power of anthems. Sue Sylvester even got in on the fun -- post cancer-ward -- by suggesting a Chemical Romance number, "Sing," and actually singing it with the class. (Middle-aged teachers performing choreographed numbers with students will never stop being creepy.) But I supposed that was nice-ish... until she revealed that she would be leading the New Direction's rival at nationals.

Kurt was M.I.A. this episode but it is assumed that he and the Warblers were serenading other retail managers at The Grove the Lima mall.

Pages: 1 2


  • zooeyglass1999 says:

    I hated everything about this episode except for, maybe, the last 2-3 minutes. This episode made me seriously question why I continue to watch Glee and why I shouldn't just ditch it the way I did with Ryan Murphy's other schizophrenic/badly written/badly plotted/poorly character-developed/all style-no substance show Nip/Tuck.

  • SunnydaZe says:

    I was walking thru my living room and tripped over my floor rug then falling onto the remote which caused "Glee" to click on just in time for the "Some people are dying; aren't we glad we're not" scene. I have the worst luck.