REVIEW: Is Weeds Running on Fumes?

Showtime's most fatale femme Nancy Botwin returns tonight for the sixth season of Weeds, though it's an iteration that even most fans will gently admit is past its prime. Maybe this once-sharp series should have ended somewhere around the time when Nancy ratted out her lover -- who also happened to be the drug and gun-smuggling Mayor of Tijuana -- to the DEA. Or maybe it should have ended when Silas started sleeping with a 30-year-old cheese shop owner in Ren-Mar. Or maybe it could have concluded at any point between the time when Shane started masturbating to photos of his mother and the time when he lost his virginity in a goth threesome?

Still, the ideal end date is neither here nor there; somehow, Nancy Botwin has survived all that and is back to take her newly enlarged brood on its most unrealistic adventure yet. Tonight's premiere picks up right where last summer's finale left off, with Nancy reacting to her son's brutal poolside murder of Pilar, Esteban's devious political adviser who, just moments before, had alluded to killing Nancy's eldest children. Thanks to one solid whack of Shane's croquet mallet, Pilar is now dead and Nancy does what any mother whose son just offed a Mexican V.I.P. mid-party does: She hides the evidence, jumps in the back of her chauffeured limo, and starts drinking vodka.

The rest of the episode follows Nancy as she rounds up her family (while intoxicated, natch) and fights off an abortion vigilante who has inconveniently taken hostage Andy's girlfriend (played superbly by Alanis Morissette), who happens to be holding the keys to the getaway van. I am ashamed to say the scene ends with a vase being broken over the vigilante's head, a difficult denouement to sit through for anyone who remembers the more delicately written Weeds scenes of old that managed to fit big, game-changing surprises (like the sonogram photo in the season four finale) into neat little boxes.

Though strong, there's only so much the supporting cast can do with these new storylines. Hunter Parrish and Alexander Gould do their best to play Nancy's sons, who unrealistically refuse to abandon the woman who's so screwed them up, though Justin Kirk -- usually the golden lining of these post-expiration date installments -- is less than ideal now that he's been relegated to the role of yet another Botwin male who will obediently follow the lead of the family's morally blind matriarch. (Yes, premium cable is all about smart females, but would it kill the network to get some men on Weeds with some residual intelligence?) Meanwhile, Elizabeth Perkins, who played the deliciously evil Celia Hodes, has left the series, and Kevin Nealon, the Dumber to Justin Kirk's Dumb, is curiously absent.

All that said, I still hope that Weeds can right itself and reclaim its position as one of the best dark comedies on television. Maybe the Botwins will re-discover their groove while they're on the run? Or maybe, like Laura Linney suggested at last month's TCA Press Tour, Nancy Botwin will open her door to find Laura Linney's Big C character waiting on her porch. Now, that -- a sum that would definitely be greater than either of its parts on television tonight -- would be worth watching.


  • You thoughts on how this show has gone wrong is EXACTLY how I feel about the show.
    Luckily, I managed to get to my friend before he finished season 3. I told him to pretend that the third season finale is really the SERIES finale- because 4 & 5 were HORRIBLE. So he listened, and now has this vision of Weeds being this perfect, 3 season show. Now I hate him, because I'm jealous. I'm stuck with this vision of a show that's WAY past its prime.

  • bradley Paul Valentine says:

    That's crazy! WEEDS is still a ridiculously fun, witty show that goes miles further into the darkest territory of human behavior than any other show I've seen. I admit thee whole Mexican mafia thing isn't my bag either. But the show is delicious television candy. Nancy Botwin remains ridiculously appealing even though she is a disgusting human being, and the show last season became all about that and the willingness of those to support her destructive behavior. It's amazing any show tries what they pull off so well. I am exasperated that every review compares it to earlier seasons. It a new animal now. I'd be terribly bored were it to go back to Aggrestic. I do miss Elizabeth Perkins.
    To each her own. I wish Movieline would actually, just for kicks, LIKE something once in a while.

  • Anna says:

    My disappointment with Weeds was that it began when Nancy was already selling drugs. I wanted it to start when her husband died, and to show how she got into it when she found out there was no money, how she made the contacts, etc. That would have been even more interesting.

  • Beeno says:

    I just with they'd all go back to Aggrestic. It's been a few years. I'm sure that it's been re-built by now. Since the Botwin's headed for the border, i've barely skimmed a few episodes since the first one at the border. I haven't even seen one second of the last 2 seasons. And I used to be Weeds #1 fan! I'm old enough to remember when Bobby Ewing was brought back to life on Dallas, back in the 80's. Let's say Nancy comes out of the shower...... and all is well in Aggrestic! It worked for Bobby, why not for Nancy B.!

Post a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s