Idol's Casey James: 'I Deserve to Go Home'

I still think Casey James is determined to make himself Idol's darkest horse ever, but the raspy singer, who didn't fare well during Tuesday's Sinatra night, told People, "I feel like I absolutely deserve to go home tomorrow if you base it on this performance." Crafty. If you thought he looked awkward without a guitar, he agrees: "I was thinking about knitting on stage as I did my song. I looked into it and there's just not enough time to get a full piece of anything knitted, in one minute 30 seconds, so I gave up on that, and...decided to go with the awkward, 'I'm not holding a guitar' move!" [People]