American Idol Recap: Who's Still the No. 1 We Want?


  • I 100% agree about Crystal's performance. I thought it was a great change of pace to show a different side of her. It seemed like she was already established.
    Let me know what you think of my recap:

  • Mike says:

    Last night was one of the first great nights of IDOL this season - I think everyone performed better than they have for the majority of this season- one minor exception being Crystal. However, with that said - I think Aaron or Michael are looking weak and tonight may be their curtain call...

  • peacefulwisdom says:

    MS CB should of won!!!! I picked both ass the best, but she has more vocal!!! Close vote.....What a shame but, I am sure that she will come out ahead in the long run of things. She is GREAT...He is Great! I would buy her CD before Lee's!

  • Barbara Hall says:

    I'm just glad it's over so I never have to hear or watch Lee Dewyze sing again. I have been listening to the AI, Season 9 CD and without a doubt, Casey sounds best on his Jealous Guy, then Aaron, then Big Mike.
    Unless someone I really like, like Harry Conick, Jr. takes Simon's place I doubt I'll be watching AI anymore. This year's winner was just too much to take.