In Theaters: Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief

Movieline Score:
percy_medusa_300.jpg

Hollywood's haste and pressure to manufacture blockbuster franchises have resulted in some spectacular landmarks (Twilight, Transformers) and duds (Speed Racer, The Incredible Hulk -- twice) of late. But it has rarely allowed for a genuine curio like Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief, the first of what Fox hopes will be at least five adaptations of Rick Riordan's hit kid-lit series. I say why not? Flaccid as this family-targeted romp can be, there's something to be said for seeing such campy, bizarro, mass-market craziness blown up for the decade to come.

Director Chris Columbus, who shepherded Harry Potter to his first two movie hits, takes on this titular, superpowered boy wonder with zeal -- maybe a little too much zeal to start with. Such is the curse of the origin story, in which a summit of Greek gods atop the Empire State Building results in Zeus accuses Poseidon's son of stealing his lightning bolt. The son -- whoever he is -- must return the bolt in two weeks, Zeus growls, "or there will be war

Except Poseidon's half-blood son didn't do it -- Percy Jackson (Logan Lerman) was sitting at the bottom of a pool at his school the whole time, blissfully unaware of his roots in the Greek mythology family tree. He's never even met his father, which is just one of the problems he has to deal with in the troublesome human world. For starters, his mother (a supremely miscast Catherine Keener, her paycheck bulging from her pocket) married a deadbeat. Graver still are the constant reminders of learning disabilities that paralyze Percy in school and in life.

But as we'll soon learn, Percy is not learning-disabled. He's just better at reading his Dad's native tongue, which comes in pretty handy between attacks by vengeful, lightning-hungry Greek nemeses. Columbus and screenwriter Craig Titley have only two hours with us, so they dump this disclosure and about a hundred others -- Percy's best friend Grover is actually his satyr "protector," schoolteacher Mr. Brunner (Pierce Brosnan) is a centaur at a camp for demigods, hot campmate Annabeth (Alexandra Daddario) kicks ass with a sword -- in about 30 minutes flat. It's enough to make the viewer him- or herself feel learning-disabled; Brosnan trotting on four legs must be seen to be disbelieved.

percy_medusa_300.jpg

All of which ultimately are part of Lightning Thief's odd charm. The bathos is almost quotably excessive ("I'm a loser! I'm dyslexic and I have ADHD!"), and I was often surprised by its indulgence in pop-culture references that no one under 25 would understand. And when Percy, Annabeth and Grover hit the road in a mission to save Percy's human mom (whom Hades kidnapped for the bolt's ransom), things just get crazy. Uma Thurman's Medusa is an endless supply of zingers wrung outlandishly into camp ("I used to date your Daddy!"); a security-guard detail-turned-five-headed hydra turns Nashville's Parthenon into a site of carnage and panic vaguely referencing the climax of Robert Altman's Nashville.

By the time the kids' quest reached Vegas -- where Lady GaGa, The French Connection, goat-hoof pedicures, and mission-threatening pot brownies "lotus flowers" coalesced in a WTF set-piece for the ages -- I was kind of dying for a sequel. And I didn't even know if I wanted it for the wrong reasons. After all, are Columbus and Titley merely hacks or evil geniuses of subversion? The audacity of setting Hell beneath Hollywood and Mount Olympus 600 stories above Manhattan seems too radical a move to dismiss, yet too obvious to take seriously. In any case, Lerman has a presence even with a mouth full of bad dialogue, and if he's gabbed himself out that Spider-Man reboot, then another sword-and-shield (and dyslexia-and-ADHD-and-hallucination) adventure might very well be worth it. And if there's a myth with a shorter title? Even better.



Comments

  • NP says:

    Okay maybe I _do_ want to see this. And possibly more urgently than _The Wolfman_ at this point..

  • stolidog says:

    Oh goody. The commercials have seemed very lame.

  • Lucas says:

    this movie has some charm. it is set in the now and in our world, not some world hidden from our world. there's some fun action flash. yeah it's campy as all get out but unlike some films, this one seems to have figured out that there's no way could wouldn't be campy and took it beyond the nines and reveals in it.
    the big worry is if they can keep it up for five films. they probably would have been better off doing all 5 at once like one giant production (skipping over the various time jumps in the narrative) so it would have a consistent look and feel. not to mention no worries about having to recast anyone later

  • christie says:

    OMG did the ppl who made this movie by chance READ the book or did they just make stuff up as they went along. It was the worst and I will not bother with any of the other percy jackson movies.

  • Mandy says:

    I read the book and I came out of the movie wondering if I liked it or not. They just changed it so much, and I was expecting something totally different. My brain wasn't ready to process it. Now, hours later, I've decided it was pretty good--not the best--but good enough. I'm actually looking forward to a sequel if they make one. I agree that Logan Lerman has a presence about him. I look forward to seeing him in more movies, even if Percy Jackson doesn't continue.

  • ln says:

    As a sixth grade teacher who with the other sixth grade teachers has really pushed the Jackson series on students who have just loved reading it, I fear the kids' reaction when we actually take them to the movie this Friday. I feel they will be very disappointed. They will have expectations based on the book, which the movie doesn't follow and easily could have followed in order to keep the real spirit of the movie. I am disappointed in Riordon to have allowed so many changes Columbus needs especially to get a different Annabeth, who was blond, spunky and a smart mouth in the book. Did she ever call percy 'Seaweed Brain!". There was nothing sophisticated about her in the book and she was actually wiser than Percy yet at times vulnerable so that they depended on each other. The fact that the characters in the book were 12-14 was part of the joy of the book for the students who read it. I agree with an earlier comment that if this will be a series, the actors just won't fit into the plot at all. I doubt seriously if students, the real fans of this series, will be likely to see the next Percy Jackson movie becuase this one just deviates too much from the book that they love. Mr. Riordon--step up and take control. Your books are great; the movie "ain't." However, if you haven't read the book, it might be ok. Afterall, Hollywood rarely follows the book and this lesson students must learn. It only makes them want to read more. I suggest someone though, and quickly, make this series into a video game, before the kids outgrow them.

  • Pool says:

    I learn the ebook and I came out of the movie asking yourself if I liked it or not. My brain wasn't prepared to method it. Now, hours later, I've made a decision it was rather great--not the finest--but very good sufficient. I'm really seeking forward to a sequel if they make a single. I concur that Logan Lerman has a presence about him.

  • poop says:

    so boring