How's J. Edgar? Critics, Comedians and Moviegoers Tweet Away Over AFI Fest Opener
J. Edgar is undoubtedly one of the flashiest Oscar contenders this year. With Clint Eastwood's direction, Dustin Lance Black's script, and the well-pancaked melodrama of Leonardo DiCaprio, Judi Dench and Armie Hammer, we're dealing with a formidable award-attractant group. But was the film's quality worthy of opening AFI Fest this year? Movieline saw J. Edgar last night -- along with a bunch of other critics, bloggers and assorted plebes -- and we're not quite sure. Here are the first 140-character reactions to the movie. (We threw in some comedian takes for the hell of it.)
Nightline's Terry Moran starts us off with good cheer.
@TerryMoran
Terry Moran In L.A. to interview Eastwood and DiCaprio about their new movie, "J. Edgar." A great film about a repellent man.
Nov 04 via Osfoora HDFavoriteRetweetReply
Screening attendee "Jingle Belle" is a little more damning (and realistic cough).
Julian Sharpe summed up what will almost assuredly be the moviegoing audience's response to the film.
Neal Brennan probably hasn't seen the movie, but he explains everything you need to know about Hoover's makeup.
@nealbrennan
Neal Brennan I'd like to congratulate Tony Clifton's make-up people for their work in "J. Edgar."
Nov 04 via webFavoriteRetweetReply
HitFix's Kristopher Tapley jumps in with a ringing endorsement.
@kristapley
Kristopher Tapley I say Leo wins the Oscar.
Nov 04 via Twitter for iPhoneFavoriteRetweetReply
Film School Rejects's Jack Giroux freely disagrees.
in reply to @kristapley↑
@JackGi
Jack Giroux@kristapley@jenyamato I think it's a really unsubtle performance in a weak movie.
Nov 04 via webFavoriteRetweetReply
And last, mine. Ahem:
@louisvirtel Judging by the acting and lighting, J. Edgar was cast at and filmed inside the world's tiniest Hollister.
Drop back by Movieline next week for Stephanie Zacharek's full review!
Follow Louis Virtel on Twitter.
Follow Movieline on Twitter.
Comments
It has its problems, mainly in the technical realm (Armie Hammer's old man makeup made him look like Old Sandy Frink in the "Romy and Michele's High School Reunion" dream sequence), but it deftly portrays 50-plus years of history without feeling like just a long checklist of notable historic moments. It feels lived-in and real. I thought it was a beautiful piece o' work.
When I saw the old man makeup, the first thing I thought was: Vincent Chase in Medellin.
I heard DiCaprio was next in line if Meryl had said no to playing Margaret Thatcher.
It may be the five martinis, but that is funny as fuck!
Old man make up, whatever. Arnie and Leo making out details please.