Who Scored Big in Week Six of SNL's Not-Ready-for-Prime-Time-Player Relevancy Poll?
OK, I've calmed down a bit since yesterday's scorecard. Yes, I still thought Saturday night was a train wreck (literally! Boom!) but I've almost been waiting for a show to come along that was so bad it would completely upend the relevancy poll. That show was this week. No more, "well, Jay Pharoah was good but he's too underused to be number one." Poppycock! Pharoah's talent (and Taran Killam to a point) really shined this week when set against a backdrop that's mostly made of sorrow. Welcome your new SNL Overlord, Jay Pharoah.
On to the poll. The NRFPTP Relevancy Poll is driven by a proprietary algorithm involving such factors as quality airtime and blah, blah blah... let's be honest, this week's poll is pretty much determined by spite. If your results differ, let's hear about it.
Pharoah's Denzel Washington is the best, and that Unstoppable sketch may have been one of the best of the season. Why is this man not playing Obama? I'm a fan of Armisen, but it's time to hand off the reigns.
2. Vanessa Bayer (Last Week: 13)
Why not Bayer? Of the SNL players not named Pharoah, she had the two funniest moments of the night between "Cribs" and "Stars of Tomorrow."
3. Taran Killam (Last Week: 9) Lost in Pharoah's greatness as Washington was Killam's cocky smirks at the camera as Chris Pine. (I promise I won't mention Pharoah from this point on in anyone else's ranking.)
4. Andy Samberg (Last Week: 6)
As the hours have gone by, Samberg's "What Was That?" has grown on me.
5. Fred Armisen (Last Week: 5)
Even though there's another guy who will remain nameless who should be playing Obama, Armisen is still Obama. Also, as said, I have a soft spot for "The Manuel Ortiz Show."
6. Jason Sudeikis (Last Week: 4)
It was good to see Sudeikis as Dubya once again. Yep, this week, that's pretty much all it takes to be ranked sixth.
7. Abby Elliott (Last Week: 14)
Thank God, I was starting to feel really guilty ranking Elliott last week after week. I like Elliott, and when given a chance, she's always great. This appeared to be Elliott's episode considering she played a prominent role in the monologue as Ke$ha and an early sketch. Then, yes, she disappeared. Regardless!
Even when Hader's working with less than stellar material, he gives it his all. Case in point: "Hollywood Dish" is pretty terrible. The only thing that makes it watchable is Hader selling the hell out of it.
9. Nasim Pedrad (Last Week: 10)
Nothing remarkably memorable, but -- all things considered -- she had a decent amount of airtime and some memorable lines in "16 and Pregnant Spinoffs"
10. Kristen Wiig (Last Week: 2)
Wiig was everywhere, but most of what she was in bombed. To be fair, a lot of her characters do seem to play well with the studio audience, but that was not the case Saturday Night.
11. Kenan Thompson (Last Week: 10)
Kenan gets credit for trying something different with "Middle School Kids," even though it really didn't resonate at all.
12. Bobby Moynihan (Last Week: 3)
Coming off of a huge week for Moynihan, I feel like a ton of his stuff that was actually good was cut so that we could see the dreck that actually aired. That's just the way it goes, I guess.
13. Paul Brittain (Last Week: 12) I actually wanted to rank him a lot higher considering that he had a speaking part (and I'm guessing a writing credit) in the Unstoppable sketch. Alas, there wasn't too much else to speak of for Brittain on Saturday. Which is a shame, considering that when he does get a chance, he's brilliant.
14. Seth Meyers (Last Week: 8)
Is Seth Myers irrelevant? He's the head writer of Saturday Night Live, so of course he isn't. And, honestly, I'm a fan. But when a night as bad as Saturday happens, coupled with a sub-par "Update," unfortunately, it's on him.
Comments
The love for Jay Pharoah on this site mystifies me. He reminds me of some annoying office guy who incessantly does celebrity impressions during meetings because one person (presumably Movieline's SNL recapper) keeps telling him how good they are. While it's possible that he's capable of humor not rooted in celebrity parody, SNL hasn't given him a chance to show that yet, so I think it's just a bit premature to declare him our "SNL overlord." I do agree that Vanessa Bayer is killing it, though.
Jason Sudeikis as GWB was awesome. But I think the best sketch was easily the Stars of Tomorrow, with the MTV sketch as a close second.
I like Jay Pharoah, but I really want to see him do more than just impressions. They're excellent impressions, but what else can he do? He did a little bit in the MTV sketch, but there's gotta be more.
Seth meyers needs help on update. The two person format revitalized update after Colin Quinn left and Seth just isn't the same without Amy poehler. How about pairing him with Paul brittain on update for the future?
Wiig far from bombed. She was aces in the hollywood dish skit and did a good job in Scar Jo's monoluge.