Johnny Knoxville, Controversial Whites Stir Up Tribeca
The night before Tribeca's world premiere of The Wild and Wonderful Whites of West Virginia, a festivalgoing friend tipped me off to the controversial film with all the magic words I needed: something or other about an "exploitative, disgusting piece of shit" documentary executive produced by Johnny Knoxville. Sold! Less than 24 hours later I'd had a scorching look for myself, with Knoxville and director Julien Nitzberg on hand to help put the debauched hillbilly spectacle in perspective. Or at least as much perspective as one can attain on the drug-scarfing, gas-huffing, rifle-toting, child-endangering exploits of America's most unapologetically dysfunctional family.
On second thought, maybe "dysfunctional" isn't appropriate. The vagaries of contemporary celebrity culture -- say, the canned drama of Kardashians, Hiltons and Osbournes alike -- require a more specific modifier for the gnarled White family tree. "Psychotic" might apply; Nitzberg's eight death threats during a one-year shoot has to be some kind of record. "Self-destructive" is a strong contender as well; after all, no 85-year-old's birthday party is complete without a marathon pot-and-coke binge. But ultimately, the chronicle of Bertie Mae, Jesco, Mamie, Sue Bob, Kirk, Mousey and the rest of their blitzed backwoods clan is nothing more (or less) than numbing.
"Overall I think they see themselves as outlaws, and they don't hide that," Nitzberg explained after the screening. "So far they seem pretty pleased. The cameras were rolling -- they knew that, and they don't give a shit. Sometimes they're kind of proud of that."
Whites arrives two decades after Nitzberg's introduction to Jesco White, son of mountain-dance legend D. Ray White and eventual subject of the cult-classic PBS doc Dancing Outlaw. "Then, 18 years later, Johnny Knoxville calls me up," Nitzberg told Movieline on the red carpet before the premiere. "He had seen that documentary and another documentary I did called The Wild World of Hasil Adkins [about another recklessly proud son of Boone County, W.V.]. We started talking about stuff, and he said 'Well, we should do something new with the Whites.' "
With the partial aid of an MTV Studios deal secured by Knoxville and evil Jackass genius Jeff Tremaine, Nitzberg journeyed back to Boone County to undertake a new family portrait. And bless their hearts, the Whites wouldn't sit still for any of it. Mamie White introduces herself first, peppering her biographical crash course with the shooting incidents that claimed the lives of D. Ray and two of her siblings, then almost gleefully promising that the trouble won't likely end there. Local officials fill in some other blanks; the county sheriff notes the Whites' "fuss, fight and party" mandate with disgusted resignation. Soon Mamie's famous brother Jesco -- the only heir to their father's dancing legacy -- guides Nitzberg on a walking tour of stores and churches he used to rob as a young man.
Then there's ex-stripper Sue Bob, whose son faces prison time for shooting a man in the face -- twice -- before engaging the cops in an overnight standoff. And pregnant, pill-snorting Kirk, who counts her failure to land a knife blow in her ex-lover's neck among her biggest regrets. And Kirk's brother Derek, who introduces viewers to the "Boone County mating call" of rattled prescription drug bottles. And Mousey, who celebrates her release from prison by hunting down her estranged husband. And all of their own kids, of course, the new generation for whom vice and unacccountability are lessons as imperative as learning to count.
Nitzberg graphically outlines the Whites' lifestyle, an armed-and-dangerous 24/7 party that no outsiders dare cross. The director is especially hands-off, rolling tape on cocaine abuse in one corner of a room while toddlers frolic in the other. Car passengers swig beer, drug deals are enacted. In the film's most genuinely shocking sequence, Kirk hoovers lines of crushed painkillers while her hours-old infant daughter sleeps 10 feet away in a hospital bassinet. She'll later be claimed by the county's Child Protection Services, prompting Kirk to rehab.
And that only occurs after a family bender that pushes the film into its own hangover. While Whites possesses almost no narrative arc beyond its string of depraved vignettes, its first half does yield a robustly guilty novelty. Pop anthropologist Hank Williams III provides songs and commentary, and the Whites' frontiersman outrage is accessible and even affecting for a while. But their pathology of entitlement -- to government money, impunity, even invincibility -- catches up with the audience before it catches up with the family. Several Whites attribute that state of mind as a backlash to the exploitation of the state's coal industry, but even so, victims begetting victims is hardly grounds for folk heroism.
Not that they'd care anyway. "Coming into this world is nothing, going out is nothing," Mamie says in closing. "But at least the world knows who the fuck we are." It's a vividly nihilistic counterpoint to the reality-TV era, or at least to a culture that handsomely rewarded Knoxville's Jackass crew for indulging its own taste for extremes. "They never knew he was our producer," Nitzberg said Saturday. "As soon as people knew that, they would do stupid--" There he paused, remembering the family he was describing. "Or even less reasonable things than they usually would. We wanted them to do the less reasonable things they would normally do, not the ones they would do trying to impress him."
Which leaves it to you to be impressed, I guess. Screening twice more at Tribeca and a lock for eventual DVD (and possible limited theatrical) release, Whites is really only as wild as its packed houses' word-of-mouth. For this viewer at least, "exploitative, disgusting piece of shit" was as hearty a recommendation as they come. But wait and see if the reality -- more akin to "cruel, bipolar slice of life" -- isn't the one that makes or breaks this film's reputation.
Additional reporting by Tara House
Subscribe to the new Movieline on YouTube
Comments
This sounded pretty interesting, until I read that Hank III was providing music and commentary. Then it sounded awesome.
I just wish someone would cover something about my state that ISN'T roughly the southern half. That part of the state isn't the whole state.
"That part" isn't even all of Boone County. I worked in the county hospital for several years and the majority of local residents are disgusted with how their area is portrayed via the White family.
I would like to let you know that I am also from the southern part of the state, and I do not appreciate your insinuating that ALL PEOPLE FROM THE SOUTHERN PART OF THE STATE ARE LIKE THE WHITE FAMILY. My husband works hard every day for his family and he brings in a lil over 75,000 per year. I have NEVER received welfare, nor do I plan to. My family is fairly well educated, with several college degrees hanging on the walls of a few homes in my family. So......the next time you think about putting dow the southern part of the state......THINK HARD ABOUT IT. THANK YOU!!
This is true!!! Not all people from the south are nearly as intelligent as the Whites are.
I'm from Boone County and you can believe that the vast majority of people here would just as soon see an end to the type of exploration and silliness concerning the Whites.
I'm from Raleigh County and I'm familiar with the Whites. I hope people do not see this and think that this is the way the rest of the state lives. But I'm sure we will be the "butt" of yet another joke. To Joe, I live in the southern half of the state and do not appreciate your comment. If you believe that everyone in southern WV lives this way you are just as narrow minded as the people who still think that we use an outhouse. My husband and I are both professional, educated people and do not like to be portrayed in this light. Hopefully no one will do yet another documentary on this people.
I also live in the southern half of the state, and I too am insulted. I stopped bangin the family goat a long time ago, because I was tired of my boots smellin like goat crap. The only virgins around here are the ones that can out run their brothers and daddys.
This state that I love is full of hard working people, my dad has busted his ass underground in the mines for more then 30 years now. Northern or Southern, West Virginia is full of plenty of hard working people. The Southern part of the state isn't much different than North Central WV anyways. I've lived in Morgantown my entire life and there are plenty of folks just like the Whites in this area. To insult the Southern part of the state is an insult all West Virginian's, we aren't so different. I for one am proud of the entire state and all the character's and rich history of this state, including the White's.
I staleness say this journal is awful. I was wondering is there anything that our blog vocation would do for group from Country ?
I hope everyone thinks the Whites are WV! Maybe that will keep people away. Our beautiful state has been raped and pillaged for to long by outsiders who do not appreciate its beauty. Our mountains have been blasted down for coal and our trees are cut for timber, who profits form this?? Certainly not us....
You know this made me think of a quote. It's something like: "All life is an experiment. The more experiments you make the better." Ralph Waldo Emerson
I take offense to the Southern West Virginia comment. I have seen this documentary, I got it on demand from Amazon. It made me want to cry and vomit because this is what is representing us. I live in Southern West Virgina in a gated community,in a house that was over 400 thousand dollars.
@ilove wv. There are plenty of areas across the state where housing is expensive. Many homes in the eastern panhandle are well above 400 (getting closer to 1 million)) Sadly, an expensive house can be right next to a family like this. West Virginia is a melting pot of people (both good, bad, educated, low income) I just wish that the rest of the country didn't have this family as the base for their opinions of this lovely state. Whenever I tell someone I'm from W.V. the usual response is "Ohh. WV. huh? Whats that like"
Everyone cares too much about what other people think. I'm from Boone County, and it is a little embarrassing...BUT WHO CARES? If people want to give you hell about your county or state, just smile at them and go on about your business. It's their ignorance of the area - not yours. That aside, I loved the film. It was a little rough around the edges, but it sports quite a few amusing and touching moments.
P.S. Nobody cares how much houses cost in WV. If people don't want to live here, you're probably not going to convince them otherwise by throwing in that we have "kind of" expensive houses in "some places" surrounded by "isolating mountains." Don't get me wrong...I love the mountains, but everyone needs to understand that you're never going to make most people believe that this state is great. Enjoy the movie 🙂
I know jesco, and yes they are crazy! I am from boone county and boone isn't as bad as the movie puts it. I know everyone is going to think the whole state is like that, but please don't think that. Because it isn't true! Do you really think that if the whole state acted like that, that they would even be a west virginia? West virginia is a wonderful place, even know we a have a couple of family's like the white family. Jesco is probally outside of his apartment now on main street living it up......lmao wow i can't believe that people actually get excited about him now..........ITS CRAZY.........we all just tired to ignore mame when she came in tudor's because everyone was scared of her lmao! And now they are both in a movie... What in the world is THIS world coming to, next time do a movie on something good about west virginia. But they movie was good....haha
All of America is like the "whites", why do ya think other county's hate the US?
It's not just Knoxville, but anybody involved with this movie who should be ashamed of themselves. What a bunch of complete crap. Let's just reward people for being backward idiots.
I've never seen such an insulting crap fest in my entire life.
This movie was amazing.
This movie only portrayed the Whites and their lifestyle. What makes you think that everyone will think everyone from WVA is lime this? Stop being so paranoid and enjoy the fact that your crappy state was at least in a movie.
Your blog was very well done. Can't wait to read more.
You have some really great unique ideas!
This video is a sad realty for many who reside WV. It is also true that WV leads the nation for people who are on the dole known as fake disability, people like the Whites. Every last single one of the family members draw a disability check from the government like it is their God given right. It is a sickening display of a system that needs oversight to get rodents like the Whites off government tit.
this is virginia jesco's niece in minneosta i dont agree what people have to say about my family... there are families everywhere are way worse then my family so fuck off and talk about yourself for once open your eyes and look around...it aint only my family that everyone hates...i work hard everyday for my money so dont say all of collect disability checks cause your wrong sir... so quit talking shit about family and worry about yours....
This video is a sad realty for many who reside WV. It is also true that WV leads the nation for people who are on the dole known as fake disability, people like the Whites. Every last single one of the family members draw a disability check from the government like it is their God given right. It is a sickening display of a system that needs oversight to get rodents like the Whites off the government tit.
I am from WV, and just saw this. NO, IT IS NOT A CRAPPY STATE!!! I was and am completly offended again!! I can't believe that people are still wasting time and money making movies about things like this in WV!!! Get over it!! It happens everywhere!!
They need to stop making these types of movies, etc about WV!! You never see any of the good things about WV. You never see anything about any other state, they just keep on producing these bad movies, etc about the bad things in WV, and think it's funny and entertaining. I have an idea!! Let's dig into their lives and their family and their past, then we will see how funny and entertaining it is!
I have lived in WV, OH, FL and GA and trust me it is everywhere! Yes people do tend to think differently of you when you tell them that your from WV, because this is all that anyone every gets to see about the state.
We all know people like the whites. Lets state the obvious .
Lower education and addiction is a repeat in action , I feel
bad for their future , and offspring .
To say they do not know why these terrible things happen to
their family , stikes me as odd .
Drugs and alcohol and anger issues is just the foundation to a
short and poor life .
I am sorry that the education and reputation did not work in their favor.
Maybe the next generation will have a better chance to rise above , a smart one is bound
to pop up.
i just recently had the oppertunity to watch the "whites" on mtv. i realize that this is filmed and put out to the world for entertainment, but i think that it has an educational side to it as well. i laughed and was saddened by this famlies story. i really enjoyed it and am looking forward to more. thank you.
Next »