First things first, Madonna was very good in Desperately Seeking Susan and A League of Their Own, which supports my theory that she's a fine actress as long as her costars are female. And especially if one of her costars isn't the city of Shanghai.
All that said: Madonna is honestly not bad in 1993's Body of Evidence, the shadowy, sexy, terrible Basic Instinct ripoff with Willem Dafoe, Anne Archer, and an august young thesp named Julianne Moore. Our girl Madge is generally effective! In this pivotal courtroom scene, she's poised, commanding, and believable. She loved, no doubt, this scene's resemblance to Marlene Dietrich's triumphant trial moment in Witness for the Prosecution, as Madonna is a declared superfan of the Blonde Venus.
Of course, any Truth or Dare moment is fabulous too. What's your favorite moment of underrated Madonna glory? Do you have one? Are you scared to?