There was a sense that, after a few recent not-so-great shows and a month off to recharge (the last new SNL was back on April 9), Saturday Night Live was due for a triumphant return this week -- especially with its most heralded recent alum, Tina Fey, hosting the Mother's Day episode in the same week that Osama bin Laden was killed. And Fey even brought Maya Rudolph along for the ride to help out. So, plenty of material to go around, right? Right?
As it turns out: Sort of. The Bin Laden reaction was, all things considered, fairly weak. And it was odd that Fey would host the show without even appearing on "Weekend Update," which, obviously, is one of her huge strengths. (Though, as you will see below, "Update" did just fine without her.) Unfortunately, it felt like Fey's appearance as host became an afterthought -- with Michael Bolton as Captain Jack Sparrow and Stefon upstaging Fey's return -- which is a shame because Fey's last two appearances has host were so memorable. Even Fey's Sarah Palin impression -- which, at least this time around, should have stayed tucked away in the closet -- seemed forced in a "Tina's the host, so we have to do Palin" kind of way. Anyway, off to the Scorecard we go...
Sketch of the Night
"Weekend Update" (Meyers, Sudeikis, Armisen, Bayer, Hader) Bill Hader's Stefon, of course, is going to get the headlines. Everyone loves Stefon! Hader breaks character! Admittedly, I thought Stefon had a fresher feel to him than the last time we saw him, which was way back in mid February. Put it this way: It actually looked like Hader was genuinely laughing this time as opposed to, let's say, enhancing his laughter for comedic effect -- for what that's worth. Regardless, everything about "Update" clicked this week: Meyers appears to still be riding high from last week's performance at the White House Correspondence Dinner, and Sudeikis as the Devil was the best Bin Laden commentary of the evening. The absurdity of Armisen and Bayer as "Gaddafi's Best Friends Growing Up" was my personal highlight of "Update" because, well, we all know people just like this. It's too bad the rest of the show didn't have the energy that "Update" possessed.
Score: 9.0
The Good
"Digital Short: Jack Sparrow" (Samberg, Taccone, Schaffer, Bolton): "It turns out Michael Bolton is a major cinephile." Michael Bolton was so good in this that he may have just earned himself top billing in tomorrow's SNL Relevancy Poll. Good on him for having a sense of humor about himself. Or, if he doesn't have a sense of humor about himself, the dude really likes Captain Jack Sparrow in the Pirates of the Caribbean movies (and Erin Brockovich, apparently). This is proof that an OK idea can hit another level by just having a more than willing participant. Where's the "Michael Bolton should host SNL" Facebook page? I'd "like" that right now.
Score: 8.5
"Mermaid" (Fey, Thompson, Brittain, Armisen, Bayer, Elliott): "Mermaid" is only up this high in the scorecard because of the brilliant concept: Undersea utopia ruined by Bin Laden's corpse. The concept alone makes me laugh, as I'm sure it did everyone at the pitch meeting. The execution, on the other hand, was... mildly amusing. Yeah, yeah, there's a 9/11 truther under the sea. OK, fine, whatever. That's the problem: once Bin Laden's body shows up, where do you go with it? Obviously SNL didn't know, either.
Score: 7.0
"Pregnant in Heels" (Elliott, Fey, Wiig, Pharoah, Killam): "I'm not so much a person as I am a collection of choices." You know, perhaps it's just the jolt of seeing Abby Elliott and Jay Pharoah featured so prominently, together, in a sketch that shocked me into laughter. Perhaps that's the key for those two: team up! Become the new Farley and Spade or the new Belushi and Aykroyd. Elliott and Pharoah forever! And nice job by Elliott for nailing Rosie Pope's "born in England, moved to America, every morning a thousand bees sting my tongue" accent.
Score: 7.0
"GOP Debate" (Fey, Hammond, Hader, Sudeikis, Thompson, Moynihan, Wiig): I bet Tina Fey hates playing Sarah Palin by this point. I bet when this idea was raised at the pitch meeting her first reaction was, "Really, guys? She's not even in the news right now. I mean, Seth, come on, you didn't mention her once at the White House Correspondence Dinner. Why are we doing this?" So, yeah, this whole sketch seemed like a contrived way to get Fey in the Palin makeup once again. Then again, it's always nice to see Darrell Hammond as Donald Trump. But why wasn't more time set aside to hammer that guy? You know, someone who actually is in the news. (To be fair, Meyers did a pretty great job of doing just that last weekend, so perhaps he felt that was enough.)
Score: 6.5
"Hallmark Mother's Day" (Brittain): This ran so late in the evening that it was tacked on after the sketch following the last musical performance -- so, yeah, I'm sure Paul Brittain was watching the clock all evening, hoping nothing went too long, because this would have been the first to get cut. Anyway, well, this was weird. Happy Mother's Day!
Score: 6.0
The Bad
"Bedelia: Sleepover" (Pedrad, Fey, Elliott, Bayer, Brittain, Samberg, Moynihan, Killam) I generally like the Bedelia sketches. And there was nothing particularly wrong with this one, but there wasn't anything particularly memorable, either. Bedelia thinks that her mom is cool -- which is the gist for all of these, I suppose. I dunno, if there were some sort of purgatory category that I could put this one in, well, I would. But taking into account that it's been awhile since we've seen Bedelia, there was plenty of time to bring something a little more fresh to the idea.
Score: 5.5
"Birthing Class" (Fey, Rudolph, Elliott, Sudeikis, Hader, Moynihan, Thompson, Wiig): I'm going to have to plead a little bit of ignorance with this one. I can only imagine that those of you readers who have gone through the process of bringing new life to our planet may have some sort of personal anecdote which makes this sketch hilarious. And keeping in mind that Fey and Maya Rudolph are very much pregnant, it seems likely that one of them had a recent experience with a video like the one portrayed. For us here on the outside looking in, it was just kind of disturbing.
Score: 5.0
"Discount Prom Wear" (Thompson, Fey, Wiig, Samberg, Rudolph): The Googie Rene saga has been an (at best) OK, near-the-end-of-the-show recurring sketch since its inception two-and-a-half years ago. The "slightly stained wedding dress" was a fun idea. "Partially damaged Halloween costumes" from earlier this season turned into a funny concept when the focus shifted from the clothes to the items that come with the costumes as a way to cover up the damage. This time, with damaged prom wear, it's just an autographed picture of Julie Chen that's used to cover the damage. Hopefully Googie Rene ends, right here, as a trilogy.
Score: 4.0
"Tina Fey Monologue" (Fey, Rudolph): I like Tina Fey. I like Maya Rudolph. And I'm not sure what happened here, but this went nowhere. I get that it's Mother's Day, but the song, coupled with their unborn babies singing, was a tad hokey. The best part was when Fey hinted at a famous impression that she wanted to just get out of the way, then burst into a fairly great Karl Childers from Sling Blade. Unfortunately, this joke was negated when Fey (again, I can only imagine, against her better instinct), went ahead and performed Palin.
Score: 4.0
The Ugly
"Osama Cold Open" (Armisen): I know that there was nobody at SNL actively asking each week for the last decade, "Hey, so what do we have for a Bin Laden-is-dead sketch this week? You know... just in case." Nevertheless: The staff had 10 years to conceive a great Osama bin Laden sketch for when we finally caught/killed this asshole, and this is the best they could do?
Score: 1.5
Average Score For This Show: 5.82
Weekly Host Scorecard:
· Russell Brand 6.35
· Jeff Bridges 6.21
· Amy Poehler 6.04
· Anne Hathaway 6.00
· Emma Stone 5.88
· Gwyneth Paltrow 5.88
· Zach Galifianakis 5.86
· Jon Hamm 5.86
· Paul Rudd 5.83
· Robert De Niro 5.83
· Tina Fey 5.82
· Jim Carrey 5.80
· Jesse Eisenberg 5.79
· Bryan Cranston 5.79
· Elton John 5.77
· Dana Carvey 5.75
· Miley Cyrus 5.54
· Jane Lynch 5.31
· Hellen Mirren 5.21
· Scarlett Johansson 4.69
Follow Mike Ryan on Twitter
Follow Movieline on Twitter