Last night Katherine Heigl made her first appearance on the Tonight Show since 1995, when the struggling actress shamelessly entertained Jay Leno with her lawnmower dance move to promote Under Siege 2. Sadly for viewers though, Leno passed up the hilarious clip reel in favor of good-old fashioned talking points -- talking points that were meant to elicit funny anecdotes, but instead led to the Killers actress choking up while discussing the death of her brother. Click through to see how Jay Leno handled the unexpected emotion, as well as the other highlights you missed last night while mourning The Tyra Banks Show.
5. Googling Drunk with Ann Curry
Little known fact: The Today Show's Ann Curry recently delivered a factually incorrect commencement speech to Wheaton College thanks to the research she conducted while drunk.
4. Traumatic Pasts with Katherine Heigl
Jay Leno demonstrates how not to deal with an unexpectedly tearful guest -- by comparing her brother's tragic death to the deaths of his distant family members and then throwing to a commercial break.
3. Ben Kingsley's Transformers 3 Audition
Sir Ben Kingsley released his very own Heidi Montag-style Transformers 3 audition last night via Lopez Tonight.
2. Maya Rudolph's Band Days
The actress and former Saturday Night Live cast member stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live! to talk about her experience on tour with Alanis Morissette.
1. No Appreciation For Matthew Morrison
The Glee star followed up Katherine Heigl's appearance on the Tonight Show with anecdotes about his bar nights in New York City and the new car he bought after his Fox series was picked up for a third season.